Episode Summary
What if penance isn’t about beating yourself up, but about saying thank you?
In this episode of Poco a Poco, the friars begin a short series on St. Francis of Assisi in the year the Church marks 800 years since his passing. After some friendly catching up, including a few wins from their recent leadership meetings and the Catholic Underground event in New York, they turn to the book that inspired the series, Love’s Reply.
When Francis looked back on his life, he said the Lord called him “to do penance.” But as the friars explain, penance for Francis was more than giving something up: it was a total and unreserved response of a heart full of gratitude for what God had given him. His self-denial, poverty, and sacrifices flowed from that gratitude and love. It wasn’t “I’m bad, so I must be destroyed.” It was “I have received everything, so I give everything back.” That’s what makes it love’s reply: love speaks first, and we answer.
The friars look at how this changed Francis. Before his conversion, his life was a life of ascent, with himself at the center, relying on himself and enjoying being the life of the party. After encountering Jesus, and especially the leper, his life became one of descent, into littleness and poverty, following Christ, who emptied Himself. They also point out that it was all about relationship. Francis did hard things the way anyone in love does hard things: because of Jesus.
They also talk about two popular pictures of Francis, the gentle bird-bath saint on one side and the extreme ascetic on the other. The friars say the real Francis is found underneath both, in a heart in love that returned everything to the Father through Christ. And being emptied of ourselves doesn’t mean being destroyed. It means being transformed.
So what does that look like for us? The friars invite us to see everything as a gift, from every breath to our families and our work, and to ask for the grace to reply with gratitude instead of just giving God time when it’s convenient. One simple place to start is a litany of thanksgiving, taking five to ten minutes to thank God for what He has already given.
Join the friars as they ask Francis to teach us how to answer love with love.
Episode Transcript
Key Takeaways
- This episode kicks off a short series on St. Francis, built around the book Love’s Reply, in the year the Church marks 800 years since his passing.
- When Francis said God called him “to do penance,” he meant much more than giving something up. Penance in this sense is bigger than a practice of austerity or discipline.
- The friars emphasize the grateful heart behind Francis’s penance. He received his life as a gift and sought to give himself back to God. This does not reduce penance to gratitude. Self-denial and sacrifice remained real parts of his life.
- It isn’t about self-hatred. The friars are clear that this is not “I’m bad, I must be beaten up or destroyed.” Self-denial and sacrifice are fueled by gratitude and love.
- Love speaks first. That’s why the book is called Love’s Reply. We don’t have to invent a spiritual life from scratch. God has already spoken His love to us, and we answer.
- Francis’s life moved from ascent to descent. Before his conversion, he was the center of attention and relied on himself. After meeting Jesus, he moved toward littleness and poverty, following Christ who emptied Himself.
- Everything for Francis was relational. He did hard things the way a person in love does, because of Jesus, not as a kind of spiritual Olympics.
- The real Francis is deeper than both popular pictures. The friars look beneath the bird-bath caricature and the extreme-austerity caricature to find the common thread: love, gratitude, and a return to the Father through Christ.
- Being emptied of self does not mean being destroyed. The goal is transformation, with everything in our lives touched by Jesus and given back to Him.
- The invitation for all of us is to see life as gift. The friars suggest a litany of thanksgiving, or five to ten minutes each day noticing where God is already speaking His love.
What This Means for Prayer and Daily Life
Start with a simple question: how often do I treat my spiritual life like a checklist I have to complete, or a performance I have to get right? This episode gently pushes back on that. The life Francis lived started with love already given, and his life was a reply.
Try a short litany of thanksgiving this week. Take five to ten minutes and thank God, out loud or in writing, for specific gifts: your breath, your family, and your work. You can also bring your difficulties to God and, where fitting, offer them in union with Christ. Notice what stirs joy in your heart, and remember that He loves you first.
If you tend to be a self-starter in prayer, always trying to figure out the right method or do everything like a particular saint, take a breath and ask a different question: how is the Lord already speaking His love to me today?
When you face something hard this week, a sacrifice, a difficult person, a moment of letting go, ask whether you can offer it as a reply of love instead of a punishment or a performance. You don’t have to do it perfectly. You only have to give it back to Him.
A simple prayer for this week:
“Lord, You have given me everything. Open my eyes to see it as gift. Through the intercession of St. Francis, help me answer Your love with love, and give back to You what You have first given to me.”
FAQ Section
Get New Episodes in Your Inbox
Sign up to receive a weekly reminder when a new Poco a Poco episode is released, along with a direct link to listen.
Support Poco a Poco Podcast
As we grow, we want to keep focusing on quality and bringing you new features that have a cost. So, in our Franciscan way, we’re asking: Would you consider becoming a monthly donor if you’ve been loving the Poco a Poco podcast? No gift is too small! 100% of donations will go to the Poco a Poco podcast and are tax-deductible. Spirit Juice Entertainment Group (SJEG) is the non-profit arm of Spirit Juice Studios. It is a 501(c)3 organization that relies on your support to continue creating original, authentically Catholic content that reaches thousands of people each week through our website and social media channels.
Start a new monthly donation and receive an array of Poco a Poco and Spirit Juice swag in gratitude for your generosity. For more information, please visit our Poco a Poco Support page.
To qualify, you must donate a minimum of $25 per month. All gifts in between will be rounded down to the nearest package amount. Please allow 6-8 weeks for your package to be shipped. Questions? Contact us at [email protected]. Your donation is tax-deductible within the United States, and we will provide a tax receipt for your records.
You Might also like
-
I Know Him
Mary wants the Holy Spirit to come to our life, as the Holy Spirit came for her. When we’re struggling, when we don’t understand, when we’re having deep desires and longings of our hearts, the Holy Spirit will come. God is good, God will send and He will give us everything, we just need to have the openness to…
-
A New Year’s Resolution
What if this year’s resolution isn’t about fixing your life, but about trusting God in the middle of it? As a new year begins, the friars talk honestly about goals, growth, and the tension between good intentions and real life. But the conversation quickly turns deeper. Drawing from the Gospel scene of the storm at sea, they reflect on the haunting question the disciples ask Jesus: “Do you not care that we are perishing?” This episode invites us to start the year not by avoiding the storms we’re in, but by naming them and discovering that Jesus is already in the boat with us. His silence isn’t indifference. His meekness isn’t distance. It’s the quiet confidence of a God who cares deeply, stays close, and is already at work. Join us as we begin the year by seeking the one resolution that changes everything: learning to trust that He truly cares.
-
Rethink Growth
One might often think that growth is gonna happen in a particular way that we usually perceive as a huge experience or something flashy, but growth might actually look different. What does the Lord want to teach us and how does He teach us…