Episode Summary
Why are so many young Catholics suddenly drawn to Pope Benedict XVI?
Gen Z grew up in a noisy, anxious, often confusing world, where identity, truth, and belonging can feel uncertain. Pope Benedict offered something different: a clear invitation into relationship with Jesus Christ. For him, faith was not just about rules or ideas, but about belonging to the Person of Jesus.
In this episode of Ask A Priest, Father Tim explores why Pope Benedict’s message resonates so deeply with Gen Z. From beauty and sacred art to silence, adoration, clarity, and the search for truth, Benedict speaks into many of the things young people are hungry for today.
Father Tim also reflects on Benedict’s love for beauty, his fight against relativism, and his quiet life of prayer after the papacy, showing why his witness feels so compelling to a generation searching for something real.
Belonging. Beauty. Silence. Truth. Maybe that’s why Gen Z gets Benedict.
Episode Transcript
[00:00:00 –> 00:00:04] Why is Gen Z obsessing over Pope Benedict XVI?
[00:00:04 –> 00:00:07] (upbeat music)
[00:00:08 –> 00:00:11] There is a love that Gen Z has for Pope Benedict,
[00:00:11 –> 00:00:12] and it totally makes sense.
[00:00:12 –> 00:00:15] Gen Z is obsessed with the vibes of the late ’90s
[00:00:15 –> 00:00:17] and the early 2000s.
[00:00:17 –> 00:00:18] But why?
[00:00:18 –> 00:00:23] The central message of Pope Benedict XVI was the person
[00:00:23 –> 00:00:26] of Jesus Christ and having a relationship with him.
[00:00:26 –> 00:00:31] Gen Z has a fear of not belonging, a fear of being alone.
[00:00:32 –> 00:00:36] And here’s Pope Benedict XVI over and over and over again
[00:00:36 –> 00:00:40] is saying, you can have a relationship with the person
[00:00:40 –> 00:00:42] of Jesus Christ.
[00:00:43 –> 00:00:44] That is everything.
[00:00:44 –> 00:00:46] And growing up in the Gen Z world,
[00:00:46 –> 00:00:48] relationship doesn’t matter.
[00:00:48 –> 00:00:50] Only your relationship with your iPad.
[00:00:50 –> 00:00:54] So it totally makes sense. Gen Z wants to belong.
[00:00:54 –> 00:00:59] So belonging leads to believing in the person of Jesus,
[00:00:59 –> 00:01:02] which leads to behaving in the right way.
[00:01:02 –> 00:01:04] Belonging, believing, and behaving.
[00:01:04 –> 00:01:06] That was all Benedict XVI.
[00:01:06 –> 00:01:10] Another example, Pope Benedict loved aesthetics.
[00:01:10 –> 00:01:13] He was all about sacred art. He was all about sacred music.
[00:01:13 –> 00:01:15] He was all about the visual.
[00:01:15 –> 00:01:18] Things looking beautiful and excellent and good.
[00:01:18 –> 00:01:22] Gen Z is all about aesthetics, even to an unhealthy extreme.
[00:01:22 –> 00:01:25] You ask a Gen Z-er to go to a thrift store on the weekend,
[00:01:25 –> 00:01:27] they will drop everything and go with you
[00:01:27 –> 00:01:28] to the thrift store.
[00:01:28 –> 00:01:29] Gen Z is all about the aesthetics.
[00:01:29 –> 00:01:33] Things looking good and pleasing and having a great vibe.
[00:01:33 –> 00:01:36] Pope Benedict was all about the aesthetics.
[00:01:36 –> 00:01:39] That the church should be at the forefront of beauty.
[00:01:39 –> 00:01:42] He said that the greatest apologetics,
[00:01:42 –> 00:01:44] the greatest way of defending the faith,
[00:01:44 –> 00:01:47] were the saints and beauty.
[00:01:49 –> 00:01:52] Beauty leads to Jesus. Gen Z understands that.
[00:01:52 –> 00:01:54] Another example, Pope Benedict XVI
[00:01:54 –> 00:01:59] was a nerd and so, so smart.
[00:01:59 –> 00:02:01] But he was clear.
[00:02:01 –> 00:02:05] Gen Z grew up in a culture that was not black and white.
[00:02:05 –> 00:02:09] It was very gray. Do what you want.
[00:02:09 –> 00:02:12] Create your own identity. Nothing is really right.
[00:02:12 –> 00:02:15] Nothing is really wrong. Everything was gray.
[00:02:15 –> 00:02:19] Gen Z can understand him. They understand his writings.
[00:02:19 –> 00:02:21] He is very, very clear.
[00:02:21 –> 00:02:24] And that is a huge virtue for Gen Z, where again,
[00:02:24 –> 00:02:28] they grew up in a culture where nothing was black and white.
[00:02:28 –> 00:02:30] Nothing was really clear.
[00:02:30 –> 00:02:33] And that has caused so much anxiety and so much pressure
[00:02:33 –> 00:02:34] in young people’s lives.
[00:02:34 –> 00:02:37] And now they love Pope Benedict because, okay,
[00:02:37 –> 00:02:39] this makes sense.
[00:02:39 –> 00:02:41] I can move forward now.
[00:02:41 –> 00:02:46] Another example is Pope Benedict XVI, he loved silence.
[00:02:47 –> 00:02:49] And he promoted adoration.
[00:02:49 –> 00:02:52] And he promoted holy hours in silence.
[00:02:52 –> 00:02:56] Gen Z has grown up in a very busy, noisy culture.
[00:02:56 –> 00:02:58] That’s caused a lot of anxiety.
[00:02:58 –> 00:03:02] They’re moving back towards silence
[00:03:02 –> 00:03:06] and towards silent prayer and towards intimacy
[00:03:06 –> 00:03:08] with the Lord in their heart,
[00:03:08 –> 00:03:11] which is diffusing the anxiety of their lives.
[00:03:11 –> 00:03:15] Pope Benedict XVI, he lived a second life
[00:03:15 –> 00:03:18] after his papacy in silence and in prayer.
[00:03:18 –> 00:03:22] And that is so attractive to young people,
[00:03:22 –> 00:03:23] especially to Gen Z.
[00:03:23 –> 00:03:26] One last example is Pope Benedict.
[00:03:26 –> 00:03:31] His nemesis was relativism. He saw that as the anti-hero.
[00:03:31 –> 00:03:33] He saw that as the enemy.
[00:03:33 –> 00:03:36] And he spent his papacy fighting relativism.
[00:03:36 –> 00:03:38] Gen Z, same way,
[00:03:38 –> 00:03:40] loves that about Pope Benedict
[00:03:40 –> 00:03:41] because they have fought
[00:03:41 –> 00:03:45] their whole lives against relativism.
[00:03:45 –> 00:03:49] Relativism says, yeah, your truth is maybe not my truth.
[00:03:49 –> 00:03:51] And my truth is definitely not your truth.
[00:03:51 –> 00:03:56] Gen Z is thirsty for truth, thirsty for clarity.
[00:03:56 –> 00:04:00] And Pope Benedict was awesome as taking on relativism
[00:04:00 –> 00:04:02] as his nemesis.
[00:04:02 –> 00:04:05] Just like Gen Z. Love you.
[00:04:05 –> 00:04:07] Praying for you. This is Spirit Juice.
[00:04:07 –> 00:04:08] Peace.
[00:04:08 –> 00:04:12] You know those questions that are tricky questions
[00:04:12 –> 00:04:15] about the faith that really stir the pot.
[00:04:15 –> 00:04:16] I want those.
[00:04:16 –> 00:04:20] Send it to [email protected]
[00:04:20 –> 00:04:23] and you might be featured on the next episode.
[00:04:23 –> 00:04:26] Spirit Juice, God answers. Peace.
Key Takeaways
- Gen Z is drawn to Pope Benedict XVI because he speaks to their desire for belonging, clarity, beauty, silence, and truth.
- Pope Benedict’s central message was not just rules or ideas, but a relationship with the person of Jesus Christ.
- Gen Z often feels isolated and anxious, and Benedict’s emphasis on belonging speaks directly to that ache. Young people ask adults to be close, and today’s digital culture can intensify loneliness even amid constant connection.
- Pope Benedict XVI says beauty matters because he believed sacred art, sacred music, reverence, and excellence can become a doorway to God, not mere decoration, but a radiant expression of divine truth.
- His clarity is attractive to a generation raised in confusion, relativism, and “everything is gray” thinking. Relativism can leave people without reference points and with a shallow, uncertain sense of life.
- Pope Benedict XVI says relativism is a major theme because he challenged the idea that truth changes from person to person, and warned against a “dictatorship of relativism” that cannot recognize anything as definitive.
What This Means for Prayer and Daily Life
If you are trying to understand why Gen Z loves Pope Benedict, start with the ache underneath it. Many young people are tired of noise. Tired of confusion. Tired of trying to invent an identity from scratch. Tired of being told that truth is whatever they decide it is. Pope Benedict XVI offers something different.
He points to Jesus as a real person we can know and love. He reminds us that faith is not just behavior or belief in isolation. It begins with belonging: belonging to Christ, belonging to the Church, and receiving an identity we do not have to manufacture ourselves. Young people, in the Church’s own listening, often ask for closeness and guidance, “points of reference” in life.
This episode also reminds us that beauty matters. A beautiful church, a reverent Mass, sacred music, silence in adoration, or a clear word of truth can reach someone before an argument ever does, because authentic beauty is tied to truth and helps draw the heart toward God.
For daily life, this means we do not have to water down the faith to reach young people. We should make it beautiful. Make it clear. Make it rooted in Jesus. Make space for silence. Offer real belonging. And remember that God does not deceive, his word and promises endure.
Gen Z is not simply looking for something trendy. They are looking for something true enough to build a life on. Pope Benedict understood that. And that is why his witness still feels so alive.
FAQ Section
Gen Z is drawn to Pope Benedict XVI because he speaks to their desire for belonging, beauty, clarity, silence, and truth. In the episode, Fr. Tim explains that Benedict constantly pointed people back to a relationship with Jesus Christ, rooted in genuine friendship rather than cultural fashion.
Gen Z loves Pope Benedict because he offers something steady in a culture that often feels noisy, anxious, and unclear. His message gives young people a path toward Jesus, identity, and truth.
Pope Benedict XVI taught that beauty, especially in the liturgy, is inseparably connected to God’s truth and love, not mere decoration. He described liturgy as “veritatis splendor,” a radiant expression of the paschal mystery that draws us into communion with Christ.
Pope Benedict XVI strongly challenged relativism, the idea that truth changes from person to person. He warned against living with no reference points and described relativism as a form of cultural “dictatorship” that treats nothing as definitive.
Pope Benedict’s clarity is attractive because Gen Z has grown up in a world where identity, morality, and truth can feel confusing. His teaching offers a way forward without pretending everything is vague.
Silence matters because Gen Z has grown up with constant noise, screens, pressure, and distraction. Benedict taught that silence is essential for authentic communication and for listening, especially in prayer, so that people can hear what is important and open themselves to God.
The Church can reach Gen Z by offering real belonging, beautiful worship, clear teaching, silence, and a living relationship with Jesus. In the Church’s own listening, young people ask for closeness and companionship, not distance, and the digital world must be shaped so it can foster bonds of belonging rather than loneliness.
Get New Episodes in Your Inbox
Sign up to receive a weekly reminder when a new Ask A Priest episode is released, along with a direct link to listen.
Support Ask A Priest
Ask a Priest is free to watch, but it’s not free to produce! Generous donors make it possible for us to continue creating this content. If you enjoy Ask a Priest, please consider making a monthly tax-deductible gift. Spirit Juice Entertainment Group (SJEG) is the non-profit arm of Spirit Juice Studios. It is a 501(c)3 organization that relies on your support to continue creating original, authentically Catholic content that reaches thousands of people each week through our website and social media channels.
Start a new monthly donation and receive an array of Spirit Juice swag in gratitude for your generosity. For more information, please visit our Ask a Priest Support page.
To qualify, you must donate a minimum of $10 per month. All gifts in between will be rounded down to the nearest package amount. Please allow 6-8 weeks for your package to be shipped. Questions? Contact us at [email protected]. Your donation is tax-deductible within the United States, and we will provide a tax receipt for your records.
-
Can You Receive Communion with Mortal Sin?
Should you receive Communion if you’re not sure you’re in mortal sin?
This question has confused a lot of people, and for good reason. In this episode, Father Tim clears up the tension between two things we often hear: “never let sin keep you from Communion” and “never receive in mortal sin.”
The Church teaches that the Eucharist is medicine for the sick—but not for the spiritually dead. Mortal sin is serious: it involves grave matter, full knowledge, and full consent, and it breaks our relationship with God. That’s why we’re invited to go to Confession before receiving Communion again.
But there’s also real encouragement here. If you’re unsure, if you’re trying to follow God, if your heart is seeking Him, Jesus meets you there. And if you’re in a place where you choose not to receive yet, that act of reverence and honesty matters more than you think.
The Eucharist is powerful. So we approach it with both hunger and honesty.
Wherever you are right now, God’s mercy is ready for you.
-
What New Year Resolutions Will Help Me Become a Saint?
Abs. Savings. Finding your soulmate. Great goals, but they won’t last forever. What if your New Year’s resolution wasn’t about your body, your bank account, or your relationship status but about becoming a saint? In this episode of Ask A Priest, Father Tim shares three New Year’s resolutions that actually matter for eternity. From spending carefree time with Jesus in the Eucharist, to daily consistency in prayer, to cultivating friendships that lead you closer to Christ, this episode reframes what it really means to start a new year well.
-
What Is Grace?
We hear the word grace all the time. But what does it actually mean? Is it magic? A platitude? Just “heaven points”? In this first episode of Ask A Priest, Father Tim unpacks the heart of grace: God’s very life within us, His invitation to live and love with Him. From the sacraments that give us sanctifying grace to those small nudges we call…
